Andy grew up in suburban Dayton, twice leading his Centerville High School teams to the #1 ranking in Ohio and back-to-back appearances in the OHSAA State Tournament Final 4. A goalkeeper, Andy was recognized as a First Team All State selection and All Midwest performer while being selected for US Men's National Team developmental camp. Andy was a three year starter at Dartmouth College, recognized as one of the Ivy League's best during his career. Krahling still ranks among the all time leaders in saves, save percentage, shutouts and wins. Krahling's extensive coaching career includes a stint at the University of Dayton. A certified referee, Andy and his wife Susan ( a standout volleyball player) have one son and reside in Centerville.